Lebanese Hebzollah in Iran?

Bookmark and Share

There have been many rumors about Lebanese Hezbollah cadres in Iran. Many observers have pooh-poohed these stories. Now we have claims of actual photographs of Lebanese Hezbollah operatives working in Iran. I am posting the pictures and a translation of an article from the website Goftaniha. The translation follows:
Click here to see the rest of the article.

Subscribe in a reader

14 Responses to “Lebanese Hebzollah in Iran?”

  1. X says:

    How can you tell who is in the photos? These photos were also run a week ago on another web site. This new story, which provides no sources or other evidence, and you tellingly fail to mention that the “web site” is a blog of a dissident in exile.

  2. admin says:

    I agree with your sentiments. If you read my post carefully, you’ll see that nowhere do I vouch for the photographs’ accuracy. They could well be photoshopped. They could be taken out of context. (Do we really know that that is the election campaign headquarters as claimed, for instance?) The whole story of how the journalist got a hold of them is murky, to say the least.
    I did feel that the author provided some possibly useful information about the presence of foreign forces in the Iranian security services.

  3. Evan says:

    I stumbled on this website and thought it might be useful in discussing this rumor.
    http://occident.blogspot.com/2009/06/lebanons-hizbullah-in-iran-rumor.html

  4. Navid says:

    Listening to telephones calls from Iran on Persian satellite TV many Iranians have called and confirmed that there were Lebanese in Tehran. There is a footage of a women who stated that they did not even respond to them when they were screaming at them and had a look of confusion on their faces because they did not speak or understand Persian and only spoke Arabic. Besides the veracity of the these reports, financially the group has a lot to lose if the regime falls (as Iran bankrolls Lebanese Hezbollah and Nasrallah would oblige his masters in Tehran).

  5. X says:

    As for “screaming in Arabic,” how would they know the nationalities of the supposed Arabs, unless they some intimate knowledge of colloquial Levantine Arabic dialects. And how would they even recognize the language being spoken? These claims are all anecdotal, and are usually cited without any way to double-check them. They are hardly solid evidence. They are also the same claims being regurgitated on Twitter with little to no confirmation, beside general claims of sourcing, such as those made by Navid.

    Hizbullah also draws significant funding from domestic and expatriate sources, which damages the “financial motive proof.” The claim that whatever replaces the regime, if it were to fall (and this is hardly a guarantee), is purely speculative, though seeing Navid’s quip about Nasrallah, which recycles tired claims and cliches, it’s not surprising he believes the Twitter rumors to be true.

    • admin says:

      Mr. (?) X (Ibn Siqili?) these are good postings, well and passionately argued.
      I hope you’ll come out from the shadows and at least give us a real email address.

  6. Ibn S. says:

    No, “Mr. X” is not me.

  7. saeed says:

    Thanks for your translation and efforts

  8. [...] Revolutionary Guard Commander Reported Resigned related post [...]

  9. Regarding remarks of “x,” when I attended a US university that had many foreign students, I could easily recognize some languages I could not speak, and Arabic was one of the most distinctive. Why wouldn’t Persians, who would probably have far more exposure to Arabic than I had, be able to?

  10. Jeremy Brown says:

    Regarding the remarks of “John Flaherty,” even if they had this “ability,” it is hardly evidence.

    And Iranians are not all “Persians,” as is often said.

  11. Al Manar says:

    I don’t know what to say to be good. Everyone can to have an oppinion, i say just our oppinion is not the same.

Leave a Reply