January 14th, 2010

The Stolen Coffin by Ahmad Shirzad

Today, Massoud’s body was buried, but left a battlefield behind. The Hezbollahi brothers had mobilized from that morning and did not stop surrounding the body for an instant.

Professor Massoud Ali-Mohammadi

Loudspeakers and electric generators and eulogizers and very high-power stereo systems and organized pickup trucks were all at their disposal. The family and its circle had practically no control and gave up on the program. From the day that Dr. Ali-Mohammadi was assassinated, the officers came and went and insisted that his body be buried during the Tehran Friday prayers. The only point that the family could get its way on was its insistance that the burial ceremonies be held on Thursday.

Massoud’s home was surrounded by a crowd from the early morning. The police had closed all the points of entry. The area was packed with anti-riot forces in uniform and a crowd of plainclothesmen who had not so much as heard Ali-Mohammadi’s name until that day. His family wished to keep the burial services non-political and as dignified as possible. Friends and acquaintances gradually assembled. The home had no space for them. They all stood in the streets outside. A large crowd of people carrying cameras were milling around looking for a vantage point to film the scene. Most of them were from our own official media. Apparently, the foreign media which had representatives in Tehran was being cautious, fearing a repeat of past experiences. Of course, foreign media or its representatives could be seen here and there, but not many.

The brothers from the government who held a constant presence in Massoud’s house during this past day or two had prepared a martial music band, a bus to transport the burial squad, a eulogizer, a grave-digger, an ambulance, and, in short, whatever they thought they needed. Little Massoud was so dear to these gentlemen! He thought of every kind of death except this one. How could anyone imagine that a military officer, a minister, the president of a university, and dozens of other petty and major officials, from the moment he was assassinated, would line up at their home so that the programs for the martyr would be done all properly and nothing deviate from the plan!

It was about eight or nine in the morning when a middle-aged gentleman stood atop the minivan and took the microphone. At first, he spoke calmly and did not chant slogans. Apparently they had promised Massoud’s family not to take partisan political advantage of the services. But “razor and beard” and all the other resources one could imagine were in their hands from the very start. They did as they pleased. The first thing Mr. Microphone did was to extol the martyrs given by the university. He spoke of Martyr [Ayatollah Morteza] Motahhari and Martyr [Kamran] Nejatollahi [doc] (a militant professor who was martyred in the course of the protests and occupation by the university students in 1979 in the Ministry of Education’s office), placing Massoud Ali-Mohammadi alongside them. Next, he took a few minutes to announce from the microphone that the brothers who were ready for the funeral ceremonies to raise their hands. About 150 to 200 scattered among the crowd raised their hands to show

Massoud Ali-Mohammadi's funeral procession

they were ready and the guy on the minivan apparently reached the conclusion that everyting was in order and that enough people were ready to start the show. The coffin was removed from the ambulance and carried into the house and they started chanting special slogans. They tightly controlled the area around the coffin and permitted no family or acquaintances to get under it.

In burying the body, one usually chants ordinary religious slogans like “There is no deity but God and Mohammad is His messenger.” But the chief slogans in this show were of the sort, “Death to Israel,” “Death to the Hypocrites”, “This trampled flower is a gift to the Leader,” and so on. At best I could say that during the entire several hours of this show in which the loudspeaker issued slogans, the ordinary slogan of “There is no deity but God and Mohammad is His messenger” was not used more than a minute or two. And even on the one or two occasions when the “There is no deity but God” was said, when those present were ready to say the second half, “America is God’s enemy” was added and they continued on in their line.

It is a tradition in most burial ceremonies that when the deceased is brought to his home and before he is buried, a few minutes of silence be observed for the household in general and the ladies in particular to bid farewell to their loved one and express what is in their hearts to their God in the language of weeping and mourning and ease their heartbreak over the body of their dearly departed. But in this show, the brothers were apparently so nervous about the details that they did let not the loudspeakers go silent for even a second and the eulogizers and the professional sloganeers played their role in this show so well with the help of their powerful stereos that no one could even hear the weeping of Massoud’s relatives. It was heard that once, one of the gentlemen even snapped at the widow! Apparently, Massoud’s friends and family had no choice but to give in. His family was anxious lest the services collapse and obstacles be created to holding the remaining programs, such as the memorial service [held after three days] and the unveiling of the tomb [held after a week] and so on. Those who loved Massoud had no choice but to offer tears and seek his elevation and forgiveness for his pure soul. They had no choice but to stand aside and surrender Massoud’s body to strangers to do the best they could. People took Massoud’s coffin whose sole acquaintance with him began when he was a blood-drenched corpse.

A bit further on, forty or fifty of the country’s physics professors and researchers looked on teary-eyed and followed the crowd, along with many ordinary people from Massoud’s neighborhood or family or circle, estimated at over one or two thousand. The people who would bury him were at a crossroad. On the one hand, they all wanted to respect Ali-Mohammadi’s soul and to bury his body in accordance with the common tradition. On the other hand, there was the show underway ahead of them, all partisan slogans and partisan participants, and few there were who wanted to appear in a picture with that mob. The photographers of the official media all surrounded the minivan leading this group in motion and steadily followed the figures who were guiding the special atmosphere which prevailed among them.

A few minutes later, something interesting happened. A crowd of a few hundred students from Tehran University, especially kids from the physics faculty, were assembled behind a picture of Dr. Ali-Mohamnmadi and were following it in silence, except when they would now and then offer a salavat. They gradually opened up a gap between themselves and the government burial squad and parted from the show which had been prepared in advance. The burial squad gradually noticed this crowd and mixed in with them and separated from the ranks of the brothers’ official show. It was an interesting scene. The gentlemen in front suddenly saw that they had been abandoned. There they were, all alone. One or two of them angrily came to snatch from the students’ hands the poster behind which they had assembled, but the crowd resisted.

Gradually, the slogan “There is no deity but God and Mohammad is His messenger” arose from the crowd and filled the street. It was so loud that the brothers’ very powerful loudspeakers could no longer be heard. As the painters say, an interesting contrast was created. On this side, there were tears and “There is no deity but God.” On the other, the exasperating blare of the loudspeakers and “Death to the Hypocrites” and “Death to the opponents of the velayat-e faqih.” On the one hand there were sighs of grief over the loss of a beloved professor whom the students adored like his children and who were now being deprived of even bidding good-bye to his lifeless corpse. On the one hand, there was there was the rage and confusion of those who were anxious about Massoud’s body falling into others’ hands and were protecting it as if it were war booty. On the one hand, there was pure love and a sincere funeral held by those who saw that they had lost Massoud. On the other hand, there were cameras and the violent domination of those who felt that they had seized Massoud. On the one hand, there was the silence of the long-suffering which was the only refuge of the eternal slogan, “There is no deity but God.” On the other hand, there were five or ten people chanting slogans of “Death” and “Infidel” which were, in practice, used to eliminate the other. As soon as the brothers saw that the situation was getting out of hand, they retreated to close the gap between themselves and the green crowd and once more take control. To do this, they even drove the minivan they had been donated in reverse, when one of the ladies shouted, “If you run someone over, don’t say that the minivan was stolen!”

Around this contrasting tableau, there was a black circle of black-clad riot officers with various equipment which had surrounded the crowd, and motorcyclists who were going to and fro. Fear and anxiety filled the air and no one knew if the services would come peacefully to an end. Our friends counted over a thousand anti-riot police. Along the way, a great mass of several hundred of them were being held at the ready in a sports arena.

After an hour of this dual burial ceremony, we learned that the gentlemen had removed the body from the ambulance to the burial site, i.e., the Ali Akbar Chizar Shrine. The participants gradually dispersed and they each tried to reach it however they could.

Around eleven in the morning, the streets around the shrine were filled with the crowd and anti-riot forces. Massoud’s corpse was like war booty in the gentlemen’s hands. There were not even any means to easily approach their crowd. At the same time, people were concerned about the likelihood of a violent confrontation with the gentlemen and did not want to mingle with them.

Massoud’s friends and students were in practice deprived of reading prayers over his body or participating in the burial service. The gentlemen performed these services as they wished. While conducting the burial, the shrine’s gates were locked and we saw bits of

Another scene from Massoud Ali-Mohammadi's funeral

the services from behind the far side of the walls surrounding it. Amir would say that this scene reminded me of the Baqi` Gravesite, which can only be peered into from behind lattice walls.

Even during the burial, the loudspeakers uninterruptedly issued slogans. No one could even hear the sound of the funeral of those few bereaved among Massoud’s relatives who had been able to approach the burial site. It was as if the gentlemen were nervous lest the previous scenario  at the burial would be repeated and the mourners would say things which were not to their liking in the course of their weeping.

It was not yet noon when Massoud was buried and it all came to an end. The grieving students returned to their residences and the members of the burial squad each went his own way. By the time the call went up for the noon prayer, there was no sign of the zealots who were worried lest Massoud’s body wind up into others’ hands. Their anxieties were at an end and they could now breath a sigh of relief and leave. If only we could have seen how many of those who had clung so tightly to Massoud’s body showed up to the graveside to recite the Fatiha. Massoud was only away from us these two days after the moment of his martyrdom. From now on, the spiritual effect which remains of him will not belong to some of those who were only present next to his corpse. Massoud was ours for fifty years, and he is still ours. It was only for one day that his coffin was stolen from us, and that’s over.

The Tehran University physics faculty will witness Massoud’s absence tomorrow and the students, despite their tears and sorrows, will earnestly strive to keep the torch of learning blazing in the land of Iran. His family, too, must get used to living without him. What a hard task! Is it possible to forget someone whose presence was felt the whole time he was here and around whom the atmosphere was filled with his energy? But there is nothing for it. One must live. God be their succour.

http://shirzad.ir/2010/01/post_165.html

Bookmark and Share
Print This Post
December 20th, 2009

Akbar Ganji Eulogizes Ayatollah Montazeri

The Historians and the History-Making Ayatollah Montazeri
Akbar Ganji
gooya new

He resisted and resisted and resisted until he became a model of Iranian people’s struggles. He showed that one could stand up to absolutist power. He showed that even if even if a  pragmatic personality attracts everyone to himself, one could still remain unimprisoned by populism and stand alone against oppression and crime. When many went to the bloodbath, he became like a spring of pure wine.

Historians, by reconstruction past events, are a sort of history-maker. Historians cannot show all of history. They are forced to choose the most important events and the most influential figures. Although history is an assemblage of the deeds of all humans, some humans have played and play a fundamental role in the course of events. History makers do not have the solution to every problem or the eliminator of every difficulty, but if they act ethically, they set the line of march and the model for the people of their time and times to come. No nation lacks an ethical model. Gandhi was the Indians’ ethical model and all the liberals believed in non-violent methods.

The Iranian revolution drew Michel Foucault to Tehran and Qom. He considered it the soul of a soulless world. But when the executions and the repression began, his view changed. Ayatollah Khomeini did not want to be Iran’s and the world’s Gandhi. When the executions and the torture began, Ayatollah Khomeini defended and in some cases, particularly the execution of prisoners of the summer of 1988, issued the the orders for the executions. But it was fated that another person stood up to the prison and torture and execution. It was he who from the start stood up against human rights violations. It was he whose hand was not stained with blood. It was he who sacrificed a post as Leader for the sake of the prisoners’ rights.

Ayatollah Khomeini’s charismatic personality could not silence him. The post of Leadership could not seduce him. Abuse and gangster attacks could not frighten him. Several years’ house arrest could not make him retreat. The clergy could not make him sacrifice them to the hoodlums. Loneliness could not weaken his courageous resistance. The widespread insults of the ruler’s men, the court mullahs, and the repressive apparatus could not break him. He did not abandon the prisoners’ families for an instant.

He resisted and resisted and resisted until he became a model of Iranian people’s struggles. He showed that one could stand up to absolutist power. He showed that even if even if a  pragmatic personality attracts everyone to himself, one could still remain unimprisoned by populism and stand alone against oppression and crime. When many went to the bloodbath, he became like a spring of pure wine. Ayatollah Khamenei was right when he said that during Ayatollah Khomeini’s last days, “there was a difficult and dangerous test.” Aye, many failed these tests. Ali Khamenei created many worldly sufferings for this great man. Now, after his passing, he wrote that these worldly sufferings will be in expiation for this resistance. He shamelessly asked God to “hide” his resistance “with the cover of his mercy.” It was not he who gave the order for the murder of the imprisoned opponents. It was not he who ordered the assassination of dissidents and nonconformists domestically and abroad. In all these crimes, he stood in the ranks of the murdered and against the murderers. He left us pure, pure.
Much has been said and written about his courage. But theoretical courage is a rare item. For someone to honestly face his previous beliefs and pour unreasoned beliefs like snow into the sunlight until they melt is a rare courage. His kept his Islamic law constantly evolving. If at first, the doctrine of velayat-e faqih had a special place, in the end, civil rights replaced the customs of the Arabs at the time of the Prophet of Islam.

His end was a new beginning. His passing gave his a new life. He showed us a new sort of connection between power and rights. he acquainted us with a new sort of political personality. If the Green Movement achieves its goals, he, too, will have in practice succeeded. It was a movement with which he had been from the start and which he was engaged in building up to the last moment of his life. He is gone and has left us alone. He has left our eyes red with tears. He has saddened our hearts. He was not only the father of Mohammad, Ahmad, Said, and his daughters. He was all of our fathers. His body will rest somewhere. But His personality will stay with us and will be our guide.

Bookmark and Share
Print This Post
October 17th, 2009

Anti-Bahai Pograms, Then and Now

I read about the impending trial and all-too-likely execution of seven Bahais in Iran as I was reading about the outbreak of Babi/Bahai-killing in Iran a little over a century before. As I was wending my way through Mirza Yahya Dawlatabadi’s memoirs, Hayat-e Yahya, I came across a passage describing the mob violence let loose against these heretics in Yazd and Isfahan in 1903. The author, who was himself called by some historians a successor to the babi_koshi_01Babi movement, appears actually to have chosen the path of a Muslim reformer. His references in this passage to Babis and Bahais reveal a feigned or genuine ignorance about the difference between them.1

In the beginning of this passage, Mirza Yahya claims that the Bahais/Babis were under Russian protection, since their main base in Iran was in Astarabad (present day Gorgan), which is in the very north of Iran and thus well within Russian’s informal sphere of influence. Since the network of Bahais (as he now calls them) were active throughout the Qajar governmental administration, they were a powerful weapon in the hands of the Russians. The British saw it necessary to deprive the Russians of this weapon and so incited the clergy against the Bahais. It is not necessary to believe in this elaborate tale of international intrigue to appreciate that the rise of foreign domination of Iran would heighten tension between the Muslim majority and religious sectarians.2

As for Yazd, there were many catastrophes. Nor did they refrain from Violating the innocent women and children of those accused [of Babism/Bahaism]. They took the suckling babes from their cradles and brought their mouths to the nozzle of a boiling samovar so that the babe would think that it was his mother’s breast and open its mouth, but insteat of milk, it would imbibe boiling water until he lost his life. One of the people of Yazd, who came to Tehran after this event, expressed his piety and courage for the author by telling him, “It was said that a neighboring merchant’s child was a Babi. He had just married and had to leave town for some reason. I went to him, cut of his head, wrapped it in a kerchief, went back to town, and presented it to his newly-wedded wife.” It was also said that in Rabi I 1321 [June 1903], in the midst of Yazd’s Babi-killing troubles, they told the ignorant teacher in a newly-constructed school that the father of one of the students had been killed after being accused of Babism. The teacher turned to that students and said, “Praise be Allah, Lord of the worlds, that they have also sent your father to Hell.” The innocent child shook and wept and wailed out loud, wanting to leave the school and ask after his father. The teacher said, “It is clear that you are also a Babi.” He bound him to the pillory and beat him for a long while with sticks. News reached his family. His young sister rushed with all her might to the school and saw her little brother had passed out under the blows of sticks and threw herself on top of him. The people attacked the school on hearing this commotion. The siblings were both killed by being pummeled and stomped to death by the people. Many such tragedies occurred. Yes, riot is blind, not distinguishing between small and large, innocent [and guilty], especially when hatreds and intrigues are involved and particularly when, in the eyes of the fanatical people, the protection of piety is also bound up with it.3

Today, “the protection of piety” is tied to the manipulation of anti-Zionist sentiment by an unscrupulous regime. Mob violence is now taken over by the State, which satisfies the blood lust of what is left of the fanatical rabble.

Another story also came to mind. During the Islamic Revolution of 1979, there was a Bahai center and a mosque in reasonable proximity in one neighborhood. A mob went off to attack the Bahai center. The mosque’s janitor, a simple, illiterate Muslim with the tell-tale stubble on his cheeks who was known to one and all, got wind of this and threw himself in front of the Bahai house of worship and talked the rabble down.

Here are some links to sites about the looming trials and related sites regarding the persecution of the Bahais in the Islamic Republic:

http://www.monasdream.com/

http://stoppersecutionnow.org/

Notes:

1 He would be traveling down the same path as others who had had a brush with Babism, such as Mirza Aqa Khan Kermani and Haji Sheikh Ahmad Ruhi, who ultimately became fiery pan-Islamists. Compare Hayat-e Yahya, Chapter 19 and Ahmad Kasravi’s Tarikh-e Mashruteye Iran, p. 136 ff.

2 Kasravi considers the Babis to have been tools of the British and the Bahais to be tools of the Russians. For his reasoning, see Tarikh-e Mashruteye Iran, p. 291.

3 Hayat-e Yahya, p. 322

Bookmark and Share
Print This Post
October 3rd, 2009

Mir Hosein Mousavi Is Intent on Overthrow

Kawsari: Mir Hosein Mousavi Is Intent on Overthrow

Source: IRNA http://www.irna.ir/View/FullStory/?NewsId=712931

Esmail Kawsari is once more beating the drums for the prosecution of Mir Hosein Mousavi. This insistence, added to Kawsari’s important public position (he is the Vice President of Parliament’s

Esmail Kawsari

Esmail Kawsari

Commission for Foreign Affairs and National Security) might presage a new stage in the repression–an attack on Mir  Hosein Mousavi himself.
–The translator

The Vice President of the National Security Commission of the Islamic Consultative Council said, “Mir Hosein Mousavi’s actions and behavior after the presidential elections indicate that he is intent on overthrowing the sacred Islamic Republican System.”

Esmail Kawsari emphasized in an interview with IRNA, “Perhaps Mir Hosein Mousavi did not at first intend to overthrow the Islamic Republican system, but by taking the course of law-breakers and riot-inciters, he has shown that he is inclined toward this.”

He continued, “Mir Hosein’s insistence on law-breaking and fleeing from the law has been conscious, and he must retreat from these acts of his. Whenever anyone, anywhere does something negative, he must anticipate the consequences.”

This representative of the Islamic Consultative Assembly added, “I believe that people like Mehdi Karoubi and Mohammad Khatami should be tried alongside Mir Hosein Mousavi and be punished in accordance with their deeds. They, too, played an important and decisive role in the recent riots and disturbances.”

Kawsari said, “These three people must be tried in a proper court for the crime of taking measures against national security and wrecking the quality of the sacred Islamic Republican system and be turned over to the law. This important task can demonstrate the system’s strength and firmness.”

The Vice President of the National Security Commission of the Islamic Consultative Council added, “Those who act outside the law’s framework and put society’s security in danger with their illogical and riotous behavior must answer for this behavior and deeds of theirs.”

In conclusion, he recalled, “The country’s judicial branch must treat scofflaws with severity. Such behavior can prevent future expected riots.”

Bookmark and Share
Print This Post